Jump to content

Welcome to SMD Forum
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Photo

Argument: Fosgate 1/0 vs. Knukonceptz Kollosus


41 replies to this topic

#1
Cashdollar2009

Cashdollar2009

    150db

  • 18+ All Access!
  • 1,558 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Greenville, PA
  • Interests:Car Audio, Hunting, Outdoors, Snowboarding, Wakeboarding, being loud.
I am not looking to purchase either, I just need an argument as to why Knu wire being tinned does not make it any worse of a wire than Rockford Fosgate 1/0. I work at a shop, and everyone here is a Rockford nuthugger, having never heard of DC Audio, Sundown Audio, Audioque, Knukonceptz, XS Power, Mechman, Singer, DC Power, Second Skin, etc. I brought in a sample of Knu Flex and all I got was: Ahhhh, but it's tinned. Rockford still has the best wire available today. Since it is tinned, the strand count is irrelevant.

I typically just shrug half of the "Rockford has da best..... errrthang" things off, but the wire is just bugging me...






P.S. I have two runs of Fosgate 1/0 in my personal vehicle as I get accomodation pricing through the shop making it cheaper than Knu, so it is not like I have anything against them, just would like a little bit more education in this area. Obviously it works, and it works great at that.

Thanks guys.

1997 Cevrolet Cavalier
Two 12" DC Audio XL M2's
Crescendo Audio BC5500d

Current Scores: 150+ out the Trunk

Posted Image

Acoustical energy is free. Electrical energy is not.


#2
Zapanater

Zapanater

    SMD SUPPORTING MEMBER

  • SMD Bronze Member
  • 509 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Missoula, MT
  • Interests:Rocks. Climbing them, identifying them, and occasionally licking them.
As I understand, tin makes it better. The tinning is so thin as to be irrelevant, and prevents corrosion. Now is one better than the other? I don't know, this is just my two cents.

2015 Subaru Outback. That is all, I refuse to touch it.


#3
jbondox

jbondox

    140db

  • 18+ All Access!
  • 850 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Cleveland, Ohio
  • Interests:F1, Mercedes-Benz, Porsche, McLaren, Maserati, Spyker, Fisker, Lotus, Hotties, Audio, Video, Installations, speed ....
I think the only one that will ever notice is the electron...

SMD SuperSeller Verified[color=rgb(51,153,255);]JbondoX[/color][font="arial, helvetica, sans-serif;"]James Shields[/font]


#4
Cashdollar2009

Cashdollar2009

    150db

  • 18+ All Access!
  • 1,558 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Greenville, PA
  • Interests:Car Audio, Hunting, Outdoors, Snowboarding, Wakeboarding, being loud.

I think the only one that will ever notice is the electron...


I see what you were trying to do there...

But that does not help my physical argument with my fellow employees and boss sir. lol

1997 Cevrolet Cavalier
Two 12" DC Audio XL M2's
Crescendo Audio BC5500d

Current Scores: 150+ out the Trunk

Posted Image

Acoustical energy is free. Electrical energy is not.


#5
Chris Hammer

Chris Hammer

  • Members

  • 4,266 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Hesperia, CA
  • Interests:MM3(N) US Navy

    MX, Streetbike, Car audio, Swimming,hiking,and shit tons of other stuff.
Whats the strand count on both. Tinned doesnt do anything but prevent corrosion. Tinned wire is beter suited for marine use etc...and should last longer in a enviroment that would cause copper to corrode.

I remember reading alot on some home audio threads and with testing someone showed there is no difference as far as conductivity/resistance/etc....but tinned wire prevents corrosion. Corrosion will only affect the wire if its at the termination/connection to you amp or ring terminal etc.

Whichever wire has higher stand count/biggest size(without jacket) is better.

Edited by Chris Hammer, 26 July 2012 - 03:46 PM.

MY BUILD *****http://tinyurl.com/gmcbuild*****
 
Vehicles
2005 GMC Canyon
CB1000r - Currently where any future funds are going. (exhasut,bazzaz, ohlins shock, screen, etc.)
crf250r - Used to be race bike..now I just trail ride..practice at the track on it.
CH80 - Daily beater (when nice weather)best 150$ ever spent. 100+mpg
 
Sold to:
Skullz - pstone11 - Leo1103 - Volvo 63' - pavelpardo - imnew59585
 
 


 

Shower farts still piss me off.

I think theyre pretty neat. When the water runs down your crack as you let one out... its like shitting in a crockpot.


#6
Cashdollar2009

Cashdollar2009

    150db

  • 18+ All Access!
  • 1,558 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Greenville, PA
  • Interests:Car Audio, Hunting, Outdoors, Snowboarding, Wakeboarding, being loud.
Fosgate: 4704
Knu: 5145

1997 Cevrolet Cavalier
Two 12" DC Audio XL M2's
Crescendo Audio BC5500d

Current Scores: 150+ out the Trunk

Posted Image

Acoustical energy is free. Electrical energy is not.


#7
RooTxBeeR

RooTxBeeR

    170db

  • Members


  • 5,302 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:708
  • Interests:Car audio and BMX!

Fosgate: 4704
Knu: 5145

By that standard, knu

Turned mine up today at a light, guy next to me his steering wheel started moving and he looked over at me like I was a magician lol.

Clip city bitch, clip clip city bitch. 10's, 12's, 15's, goin up in flames bitch.

fuck the plating. look at what the main metal used is. you could buy unicorn blood plated terminals but if its just covering up dog shit, whats the point


I'll admit, half way through sanding that fiberglass in the rain and cold while I was all itchy I was definitely starting to question why i was doing this haha

Old Deceased Build
'91 Honda Civic Hatchback
 
Current Build
 
'04 Ford Escape
 
1Awg positive run to the back 
TORK2 kit from Tony @ CE Auto Supply
Pioneer DEH-80PRS
Rockford R1652-S In Front
Rockford R1675 In Rear
RF R300-4
AQ750 @ 1 ohm
8.0Cuft box @ 32Hz
(2) 15" Skar IVX-15

#8
Cashdollar2009

Cashdollar2009

    150db

  • 18+ All Access!
  • 1,558 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Greenville, PA
  • Interests:Car Audio, Hunting, Outdoors, Snowboarding, Wakeboarding, being loud.
Obviously Knu is cheaper to the average consumer, and obviously Knu has a higher strand count, so why would it not be considered a better wire?

I am just trying to make sure 100% that it is just their erection for Rockford, and not mainly his 18 years of experience saying that it being tinned deems it less effective for a dry, car stereo application. Assuming that neither vehicle will be playing in flood waters.

The only valid points, well, that I would consider valid is that pure copper is a better conductor than tin, so if the tin content is high enough, it may leave less copper than what is present in the Rockford wire.

1997 Cevrolet Cavalier
Two 12" DC Audio XL M2's
Crescendo Audio BC5500d

Current Scores: 150+ out the Trunk

Posted Image

Acoustical energy is free. Electrical energy is not.


#9
Chris Hammer

Chris Hammer

  • Members

  • 4,266 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Hesperia, CA
  • Interests:MM3(N) US Navy

    MX, Streetbike, Car audio, Swimming,hiking,and shit tons of other stuff.

Fosgate: 4704
Knu: 5145


I seem to remember from the thread that directly compared wire that Knu was also larger after being stripped. Both OFC but the knu has higher strand count, larger, tinned. Knu's the winner in my book. BUT...would I hesitate to use the Rockford wire.....No i would use that if I got a deal on it..and I wouldnt look back.
MY BUILD *****http://tinyurl.com/gmcbuild*****
 
Vehicles
2005 GMC Canyon
CB1000r - Currently where any future funds are going. (exhasut,bazzaz, ohlins shock, screen, etc.)
crf250r - Used to be race bike..now I just trail ride..practice at the track on it.
CH80 - Daily beater (when nice weather)best 150$ ever spent. 100+mpg
 
Sold to:
Skullz - pstone11 - Leo1103 - Volvo 63' - pavelpardo - imnew59585
 
 


 

Shower farts still piss me off.

I think theyre pretty neat. When the water runs down your crack as you let one out... its like shitting in a crockpot.


#10
Chris Hammer

Chris Hammer

  • Members

  • 4,266 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Hesperia, CA
  • Interests:MM3(N) US Navy

    MX, Streetbike, Car audio, Swimming,hiking,and shit tons of other stuff.

Obviously Knu is cheaper to the average consumer, and obviously Knu has a higher strand count, so why would it not be considered a better wire?

I am just trying to make sure 100% that it is just their erection for Rockford, and not mainly his 18 years of experience saying that it being tinned deems it less effective for a dry, car stereo application. Assuming that neither vehicle will be playing in flood waters.

The only valid points, well, that I would consider valid is that pure copper is a better conductor than tin, so if the tin content is high enough, it may leave less copper than what is present in the Rockford wire.


I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure that when they "tin" the copper wire they use the electroplating method..... The amount of other metal present on the surface of the wire is so small i would consider it negligable.
MY BUILD *****http://tinyurl.com/gmcbuild*****
 
Vehicles
2005 GMC Canyon
CB1000r - Currently where any future funds are going. (exhasut,bazzaz, ohlins shock, screen, etc.)
crf250r - Used to be race bike..now I just trail ride..practice at the track on it.
CH80 - Daily beater (when nice weather)best 150$ ever spent. 100+mpg
 
Sold to:
Skullz - pstone11 - Leo1103 - Volvo 63' - pavelpardo - imnew59585
 
 


 

Shower farts still piss me off.

I think theyre pretty neat. When the water runs down your crack as you let one out... its like shitting in a crockpot.


#11
jbondox

jbondox

    140db

  • 18+ All Access!
  • 850 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Cleveland, Ohio
  • Interests:F1, Mercedes-Benz, Porsche, McLaren, Maserati, Spyker, Fisker, Lotus, Hotties, Audio, Video, Installations, speed ....


I think the only one that will ever notice is the electron...


I see what you were trying to do there...

But that does not help my physical argument with my fellow employees and boss sir. lol



I am no physicist, but love physics, however, there shouldn't even be an argument. I always loved these arguments in the past, and used to tell everyone to open up their amp and explain the little traces that need 1 awg going to them. so basically, unless you are in the wire selling business, both will skin the cat... marketeers are the ones that swear buy it, which i will be happy to ask; "Can you hear the difference between the 441 strands not being used?"

SMD SuperSeller Verified[color=rgb(51,153,255);]JbondoX[/color][font="arial, helvetica, sans-serif;"]James Shields[/font]


#12
b-dubs89

b-dubs89

    135db

  • Members
  • 605 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:minnesota
  • Interests:moving air , good music on a good system , chess ,tinkering , things of scientific nature
i have the rf 0 gauge dual amp kit , and i also have some knu 10 gauge speaker wire they both seem to be some good quality wires , the only thing i have noticed between the knu and rf stuff that i have is that the rf takes solder easier than the knu that i have .



Reply to this topic



  


0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users