Jump to content
Sonic Electronix

Sealed vs. Ported box - experience.


Recommended Posts

Hi guys,

I am about to embark on my first sound system build in my MY00 Subaru Impreza. Though, I have found myself tossing up between both types of boxes considering their benefits. Note: I have only ever heard ported systems in real life.

I mainly listen to trance/club music, but also listen to many other genres.

I'm just wondering has anybody had first hand experience with both sealed and ported boxes to tell me what would sound best playing trance/club music?

Decided to go with an Dual voice coil 4 ohm Alpine type s 10" sub (1500w), which is to be powered by a Hifonics 1500w D class mono block.

Personally I haven't had a lot of experience around quality systems and am a noobie in the audio world, so advice on boxes would be appreciated!

(1) Single din Kenwood headunit

(1) Alpine Type S 12" SWS-12D4 (500wrms)

(2) Kicker CS65 coaxial 6.5" mid's (100wrms)

(1) MB Quart Mono Block Amplifier (500wrms)

(1) Rampage 4 Channel Amplifier (1200wrms)

(1) 2nd Hand Ported Box (prefab) (estimated 1.7-9 cubes tuned @35-37hz)

(1) MB Quart Bass Knob

Stinger wiring and RCA's.

(Unmetered daily setup)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you want loud harder hitting bass go with ported. if you want tight sound quality bass then go with sealed

09 Challenger R/T (Audio system under construction):

  • Pioneer AVH-X4500BT (PAC RP4CH11 harness)
  • (2) Sundown Audio SA-8v2 (inverted)
  • CT Sounds AT1400.1D
  • XS Power D3400
  • 40 sq ft. Audiotechnix deadener
  • 1/0 Audiotechnix wiring
  • stock Boston Acoustic 7 speaker amplified system (for now)
  • Sealed trunk enclosure

Build log:

http://www.stevemeadedesigns.com/board/topic/178399-slammed-dodge-challenger-sundownct-sounds-build/

TEAM GOAT

signature-1.jpgsubsignature.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

^^^^...^^^^

2006 P71

270A Mechman alt.

2 XS power D3100's, 1 under the hood, one in the trunk. More to come.

2 Stinger 0 gauge, 4 gauge runs front to back

Sony DSX-S300BTX AM/FM Digital Media Car Stereo with Bluetooth

Pair of Fi SP4 15''s

B2 Audio M1s MKII amp @ 1 Ohm

Front doors JBL P660C 6.5'' 2-way component system.

Rear doors JBL GT0938 6x9'' 3-way

Rockford Fosgate t600 @ 2 Ohm

Ram Designs box with 5'' port, ~ 3.6 cubic inches each facing back.

5704P Python 2-Way Responder Remote Start / Security Alarm. :shrug:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks, but I was more so wondering your opinions on what you believed actually sounds better for that music type. Looking down the scope of a ported box, but my buddy seems to think that the sealed boxes are king for techno.

(1) Single din Kenwood headunit

(1) Alpine Type S 12" SWS-12D4 (500wrms)

(2) Kicker CS65 coaxial 6.5" mid's (100wrms)

(1) MB Quart Mono Block Amplifier (500wrms)

(1) Rampage 4 Channel Amplifier (1200wrms)

(1) 2nd Hand Ported Box (prefab) (estimated 1.7-9 cubes tuned @35-37hz)

(1) MB Quart Bass Knob

Stinger wiring and RCA's.

(Unmetered daily setup)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks, but I was more so wondering your opinions on what you believed actually sounds better for that music type. Looking down the scope of a ported box, but my buddy seems to think that the sealed boxes are king for techno.

its all personal preference honestly. but as far as techno goes i seem to notice most bass notes are short and to best produce those short tight bass notes would be a sealed box.

A ported box would be better for producing those long held notes, from my observations at least. Ported isn't the best sounding when it comes to precision of notes, hence the lack of sound quality compared to a sealed box

09 Challenger R/T (Audio system under construction):

  • Pioneer AVH-X4500BT (PAC RP4CH11 harness)
  • (2) Sundown Audio SA-8v2 (inverted)
  • CT Sounds AT1400.1D
  • XS Power D3400
  • 40 sq ft. Audiotechnix deadener
  • 1/0 Audiotechnix wiring
  • stock Boston Acoustic 7 speaker amplified system (for now)
  • Sealed trunk enclosure

Build log:

http://www.stevemeadedesigns.com/board/topic/178399-slammed-dodge-challenger-sundownct-sounds-build/

TEAM GOAT

signature-1.jpgsubsignature.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks man, I think I'll give both a go and just see what I like best!

(1) Single din Kenwood headunit

(1) Alpine Type S 12" SWS-12D4 (500wrms)

(2) Kicker CS65 coaxial 6.5" mid's (100wrms)

(1) MB Quart Mono Block Amplifier (500wrms)

(1) Rampage 4 Channel Amplifier (1200wrms)

(1) 2nd Hand Ported Box (prefab) (estimated 1.7-9 cubes tuned @35-37hz)

(1) MB Quart Bass Knob

Stinger wiring and RCA's.

(Unmetered daily setup)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you want loud harder hitting bass go with ported. if you want tight sound quality bass then go with sealed

you can make ported boxes "tight and sound quality bass" too. just gotta know what you are doing.

Buyer/Seller Feedback Thread: http://www.stevemead...5015-bump4life/
MB C220 153 Trunk Car Build Log: http://www.stevemead...d/#entry1840136
MB C280 Ipad Dash SQ Build Log: http://www.stevemeadedesigns.com/board/topic/194484-bump4lifes-new-benz-tony-c-relay-kit-pictures-ce-electric-audison-front-stage-installed/
My SPL Log: http://www.stevemead...__fromsearch__1

BMW M340 xDrive

Stock, for now. Corner Load 10" maybe soon. But does 10s in the 1/4...
Best Scores out of a trunk
153.0 sealed legal full tilt clamped 5524 @ 42 hz
154+ windows down, 155+ kick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sealed enclosure for trance...

Ported enclosures will gives the kick a delayed response. Almost as if the kick is on the off beat.

Yes you can design a ported enclosure for "tighter" response but for simplicity's sake...sealed.

Avalanche

Alpine Type S comps

Alpine Type S 10''

Alpine MPR-F300

Alpine MRX-M50

Mechamn 270

XS Power d3400s



 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you want loud harder hitting bass go with ported. if you want tight sound quality bass then go with sealed

you can make ported boxes "tight and sound quality bass" too. just gotta know what you are doing.

just depends on the build. if this is your first box i say do some research on ported boxes and just go sealed for now. I had a fosgate p2 12 in my car on both boxes and the ported sounded better than the sealed. even on tight punchy notes. its all about how the box is built with ported.

once you get a speaker moving so hard that its possible to make tinsels slap, you are already kissing "SQ" goodbye. :D

Don't get me wrong, as I smoke Marlboro Reds, but if I saw one more kid with that smug-ass look (Look at me I'm smoking indoors) on their face, I was going to shove that thing so far up someone's ass that they'd look like a hillbilly trying to understand quantitative prediction theorem.

You know why people are ass holes online but not in person? Because getting punched in the mouth hurts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i agree on sealed for the sole reason of lack of experience. I have a ported enclosure and i can play double kick very well on it. Nice and tight no muddiness. But it can play booming lows in stuff like dub and rap very well too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Who's Online   0 Members, 1 Anonymous, 954 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...