There were going to be momentum changes throughout the game regardless of Colt getting hurt. Would Texas have been a totally different team with him? DUH, of course, but Alabama would have been different too. Alabama completely changed their game plan when he went out. There is no way you can say Texas would have won with him because he went out so early. You might as well say first team to score wins because there is no way a team can make changes and adapt, there is a reason games are 60 minutes long.
Ps: I think some of the band wagon fans are SEC fans. I know I was cheering for Bama simply because they are SEC.