i like the idea of 10" Level 5s.. thorshammer could always use some more competition..
2 12"s in the right box can outperform 2 15"s in a poorly designed box, and since you will have the space to build a proper box for 12"s, that seems like a good way to go..
of course, wood is cheaper than subs, so you could try rebuilding your current enclosure 1st..