Eh, I dont think you can say you'd get better sound quality from the skar. It's really going to depend on the box you make. But both these dubs murder the lows, from what I've been seeing the Skars might even like to play a tiny bit lower. But honestly either sub will rock your shit just fine my friend. And about the kicker and jl nuthuggers, they swear by their shit but I promise 99% arnt as loud as the average person on this site who has spent much less money. And most those homos go and put their shit in some prefab box which shows just how much they don't know about this game. The box is where its at