Both are good as with any battery you have to keep them charged up with either a solid enough alt for your project and or a good charger for them. Listening to a 4500ish watt system loud most of the time to where the vehicle is falling apart can yield a bad less than 1 year old stockish battery under the hood that won't charge past 12.4 volts and a 4000+ watt battery with slight ballooning that won't charge past 12.7 when it use to charge up to 13. The system is about 1 year old or a little more. Thinking it has a 3 year warranty but I doubt it would be covered because a ballooning battery is an overcharged battery..