if someone is making money by using copyrighted material that they dont have permission to use, and they finally get caught up to, then i dont understand how possibly defeating that is progress.
for people NOT gaining from it financially, then there should be no limitation. but partners should not be able to use copyrighted material without permission, and if they do and they get caught there should be no chance to defeat the accusation, and my opinion is they should be removed from youtube.
sure, if the artist feels that way. But if one of my favorite artists tells me to my face that they love my video's and want me to keep making them, it shouldn't be up to youtube to take the liberty to take it down.