Jump to content

Leaderboard

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 01/23/14 in Posts

  1. is it a repost? fuck it if it is...this is my site. hahah
    7 points
  2. Man...this thread... Let's sum it up, AMM-1 is not the only way you can get reasonably accurate power results. Using a scope with true rms clamps and meters will get you there. That being said, the AMM-1 takes alot of the work and math out of it for those who could not do it otherwise. It's a tool, like any other tools, there is always another way. If you use a jig saw to make your sub cut outs why buy a router and circle jig? Because it is easier to get good results. But that doesn't mean the guy who uses the jig saw is suddenly doing it wrong. The same logic can be applied to this situation. Clamping with the right tools and knowhow will give you accurate results. Im sure this is why Taylor and that sinterman dude as well as myself are frustrated after reading through here and watching the vid, since it is suggesting that clamping will never be accurate which is really not the case. I think the AMM-1 is an awesome tool but it's just kinda shitty to start misleading the general audio community for a marketing campaign...intentional or not, it's happening
    6 points
  3. Soooooooo you're saying that a lead designer from Rockford Fosgate doesn't know how to measure the output from an amplifier correctly....? I would suggest some research before you make accusations...
    5 points
  4. Most handheld meters already measure RMS, not peak. So there's no need to multiply by 0.707 unless you're looking at peak numbers from an o-scope. Ohms Law is fine.......for DC. Doesn't directly apply for AC (amplifier output). Tony has a whole string of vids to teach people the basics:
    4 points
  5. 4 points
  6. so I can buy all those tools and a concrete bucket or 1 single tool? geez, tough choice. but I do see that guys point, this isn't the only tool that works. But, I will let him use the concrete bucket...
    4 points
  7. The reason it's misleading is that it's not utilizing the reason clamping is flawed- reactive loads (like subs). Unless you believe that very nice scope-meter is off by almost 20v. You actually don't even *need* the clamp meter in this clamp because it's on fixed resistance. The other thing is that this isn't the best way to show how the AMM-1 is better and easier than traditonal clamping. Take a look at my test rig... That's a lot of f'n shit to watch. The AMM-1 "watches" it all for you and spits out the number you're after with all of that crap. For "clamping" and doing it the most accurate way that you can, the AMM-1 is a no brainer. For hardcore amp testing... it can be done cheaper than the AD-1 with very accurate and consistent results. But that's another thread entirely. My whole point of chiming in on this vid is that the AMM-1 basically sells itself. You don't *need* to have a BS demonstration like this to mislead people. Do the test on subs with clamping vs. the AMM-1. That's the point. It's a great way to show how the AMM-1 is spot on with the AD-1 (awesome), but the clamp portion is flawed and misleading. All I'm suggesting is to redo the video. If you want to discredit clamping, at least do it correctly.
    4 points
  8. not going to take sides cause i don't really give a shit. I am enjoying the debate and seeing all the experts and "experts" chiming in. Please continue.
    4 points
  9. 3 points
  10. This is getting interesting. Looks like a lot of people are taking this video the wrong way. We obviously have a couple of people in here that do have an idea how to properly use clamps on a resistive load. But how many people really do? I will be more than happy to redo the video and show more detail. Here are a few facts 1) on a resistive load, dyno and clamping should match. 2) dyno tells you the number straight up, to find the correct nber while clamping, you have to watch the sine wave to find the point that you think is just at or before clipping. 3) how many people that clamp, do it with a scope? Not many. Most use a dmm and cheap clamp. Even using a resistive load, you can't see your sine wave on a dmm so you just take the biggest number. Not accurate.
    3 points
  11. You should manufacture and sell your bucket-o-concrete meter. Sounds profitable. The shipping costs might suck though. I remember when we stared 3 years ago, someone told us "I could build a DD-1 with $10 of parts from Radio Shack". I'm still waiting to see it.
    3 points
  12. No matter what tool you come up with Tony, there's always haters that smater than u
    3 points
  13. Problem solved, test concluded....... let butt hurt continue. TonyD for Prez....
    2 points
  14. Everyone is gonna become mazda2442 now..
    2 points
  15. All I gotta say is amm-1 is a great tool. Pricey but good tool. Prolly best smd tool to date. Video showed clamp wrong. Admit it and move forward. How hard is it to make another 4 minute video? Someone who doesn't read through all these pages or watches video on Facebook or YouTube are going to be mislead. Your product can sell itself, doesn't need to put others down in false ways to sell it. For clamping in a car to see real power this tool is probably the easiest most affordable out there. Are there other ways, yes but this tool will eliminate all human error and be dead on everytime. Awesome stuff.
    2 points
  16. the way i see it is that is much easier to use the amm-1 then to get 3 tools to do what one can.. i would buy the amm-1 just because of the simplicity.. clamping can be close to accurate but it has to be by one that knows and understands it and has the correct tools. the amm-1 can be used by new people to the hobby
    2 points
  17. And the great shit storm of our time has come... I believe everyone in here has said that there is a somewhat accurate way to clamp, correct? We can agree on that? Good. What we're trying to get at is that instead of using 3 different tools and only being able to truly test non-reactive loads, you can use one tool, save yourself the time and hassle, and have a truly accurate reading in your car and see where your system is at. There's no smoke and mirrors here, what you see is what you get.
    2 points
  18. I understand what he is saying as well, just giving him a hard time. Jokes aside, even if that setup worked, you would then know how many VA your amplifier can put out into a bucket of concrete. Still wouldn't tell you how many Watts your amplifier puts into your SPEAKERS
    2 points
  19. Do we have anyone art-sy in here? I'd love to see a sketch of a guy dynoing an amplifier with a bucket of concrete with a pos scope, a voltmeter, a clamp meter, and a calculator attached to it.
    2 points
  20. Ask and ye shall receive. Stole these from Tony on FB. THIS is what I'm talking about. This is a comparision of "traditional" clamping on the left and right and the AMM-1 in the center ON A REACTIVE LOAD (subs). This is 34v and 6.2a. Traditionally we would do the math and come up with 211w rising to 5.5ohms. You can see the AMM-1 will tell you that too (if you want to know). NOW.... here is where the AMM-1 shines. You don't need fixed resistance or a dual input trillion dollar scope. The AMM-1 is calculating it all for you! Bingo. Clamping pwned.
    2 points
  21. For anyone that wants more info on AC power measuring or would just like a good read here ya go. http://www.ibiblio.org/kuphaldt/electricCircuits/AC/AC_11.html#xtocid174221
    2 points
  22. HAHA cheap clamp. http://www.testequipmentdepot.com/products.htm?item=353&ref=gbase&gclid=CPa_soijk7wCFVQV7AodIWYA-g
    2 points
  23. You crack me up. Cheap meter? Do you even know who/ what Fluke is. Go do your homework.
    2 points
  24. The point of this test wasnt to bash clamping, it was really to show the accuracy of the AMM1. Here is a breakdown of the test. Amp Dyno is being used to provide a 4Ω resistive load. On paper, the clamps, Dyno, and AMM1 should all agree on the same number since the load is resistive and the power factor is 100%. Here is where the tricky part comes in. If you are "clamping" using just a general DMM, there is no way for you to see where clipping occurs. Now if you use a nice Oscope, you can now see the sine wave. BUT you are having to rely on your eyes to tell you where clipping occurs to find out what the numbers are at this point to find your usable power. Once you take this into your vehicle and start using a subwoofer to create your load, now you run into phase angle which clamps cannot see. Overall the AMM1 does everything for you and make it MUCH MUCH easier. It is an all in 1 tool.
    2 points
  25. I'm not bashing the dyno or the AMM-1. Or even taking up for clamping for that matter, but the way the test was done using the dyno for the clamp portion isn't the best way to illustrate the difference. Cody retested the amp. He videoed the clamped portion this time. This is a screen shot of the 900w clamp result. Pay particular attention to the wave on the scope-meter The dyno and AMM-1 stop reading at 1% THD. Does that look like 1% to you? Yeah... me neither. This is much closer. This is a screen shot of the same vid, but while the wave is still clean. That's 570w and MUCH closer to what the dyno and AMM-1 are seeing. Clamping is flawed because of the phase angle on reactive loads. But he isn't using a reactive load here, is he?
    2 points
  26. iirc They way he clamped is not the correct way. I saw a video from Tony D'Amore that showed the correct math to use to clamp an amp, it's more that just multiplying and dividing two numbers
    2 points
  27. Were thinking about offering these as a more available option. We have always been able to make them but just started thinking if we made some in advance and offered it as a option, how many people even mount there amps in a way that they could use them?
    1 point
  28. You won't find one N8. If you search his history on CACO or character in general he's the epitome of read, hear, and repeat but no first hand knowledge or experience. Not to mention an incredible disdain for SMD, the forum and person, and Damore. I don't say this to stir the pot, I say it because once you realize the true nature you can remove the facade of objectivity. He even made a thread asking why people used getting loud as a rebuttal in debates and why doesn't someone who doesn't compete or get loud get taken seriously. I'm honestly surprised he's here at all. I can see the point being made and know Cody will step up yo the plate. I know people who test things in their own like myself or Taylor can sympathize how much effort goes into helping and people can seem ungrateful. I love the AMM 1 as I didn't have to pay more money since I no longer work in a custom shop.
    1 point
  29. How about this, would you like me to redo the test and use only a TRMS Multi meter. THen how are you going to know the point where clipping occured? The only thing wrong with what I did may be the way I come across on the video instead of explaining why there is such a drastic difference. Here is the fact of the matter. 99% of people who clamp are going to do exactly what I did. Take the biggest number you see and claim it as watts. i agree with you, most will take the max true rms and dont even know what an o-scope is. most dont know what power factor is, for most, this video will show them how far off they are. but for people who do it right and have all proper tools, this video is completely wrong. i could care less if you re-do it, but at the end of the day , if you showed people how to properly clamp in this video none of the arguments would be made in this thread. and the amm-1 wold look even better since you dont have to do any calculations or readings and you dont need more than one person to clamp. please understand im not trying to argue, but this video can be misleading.
    1 point
  30. How about this, would you like me to redo the test and use only a TRMS Multi meter. THen how are you going to know the point where clipping occured? The only thing wrong with what I did may be the way I come across on the video instead of explaining why there is such a drastic difference. Here is the fact of the matter. 99% of people who clamp are going to do exactly what I did. Take the biggest number you see and claim it as watts.
    1 point
  31. I understand what he is saying as well, just giving him a hard time. Jokes aside, even if that setup worked, you would then know how many VA your amplifier can put out into a bucket of concrete. Still wouldn't tell you how many Watts your amplifier puts into your SPEAKERS oh I did miss that part. I don't understand nearly enough about this stuff at this level. I do know I have no reason to know how much power I can put into a concrete bucket!
    1 point
  32. Are we talking 5 gallon bucket or some other size? I'd hate to build this thing and get the wrong reading cause I used the wrong bucket. How bout the concrete?
    1 point
  33. I understand what he is saying as well, just giving him a hard time. Jokes aside, even if that setup worked, you would then know how many VA your amplifier can put out into a bucket of concrete. Still wouldn't tell you how many Watts your amplifier puts into your SPEAKERS You should post the vid of you showing what the AMM-1 can do. That might clear up some things.
    1 point
  34. See now this to me is where it gets interesting. Now since you are posting a cheaper alternative people have choices. From the clamp tests I've seen people do it's a dmm and clamp, this is my first time seeing a scope or true rms meter for such a low price. Still comes into factor of how well the user can see clipping on the scope. It would be nice to see a comparison of equipment like what sintorman posted and the amm1.
    1 point
  35. I'm not against the amm1.. Seems like a neat tool. However I am against people making videos misusing equipment and praising the equipment that was used properly. It's just low.
    1 point
  36. You are looking at about $5000 worth of testing equipment sitting on my make shift bench. I have the tools to do the job correctly, most people dont. The AMM1 now provides an affordable solution that. That's what i'm trying to say, with cost difference between the tools needed to get an accurate test the amm1 is a hands down winner. Yes clamping with the right tools can give you More accurate result but still not 100% and not as cost effective. Let's face it us audio guys are always looking for a good way to save money while still getting the install done right. The amm1 helps do that plus some with ease and accuracy. Sorry if anyone feels like i'm baking clamping, not trying to. It's the way of the past and inaccurate compared to the amm1. For a cost effective tool the amm1 is a steal. Unless the amm1 is cheaper than 250 bucks then it's actually not the better deal. But if you honestly need something that can measure taking into account for the power factor then I guess spend the extra money. 99% of people don't do it and so the industry standard is basically clamping for voltamps. And VA isnt watts.
    1 point
  37. The video is staying up. I will make sure to really hurt the clampers feelings when I test the AMM1 vs Clamping using a Subwoofer. Point of this. AMM1 very simple. Clamping- To find the exact point, you have to video it and then go back to watch that video to try and find the point just before clipping. Pain in the ass.
    1 point
  38. you are about a day late and a dollar short bro haha sorry! next one is coming soon -
    1 point
  39. The first 5 minutes of Video 5 on this page describe why a DMM and clamp become inaccurate if the signal clips at all, even if they are "True RMS" meters. What is RMS? Find out here http://www.damoreengineering.com/freeeducation.html
    1 point
  40. sure clamps are still good for what they are GOOD at. This isn't one of them. An electrician "Checking Electricity" (LMAO BTW) and your buddy measuring amp output in his garage is not the same thing. Just sayin'.
    1 point
  41. i know he made it...but i didn't see he posted it anywhere...but then again this forum is so damn busy i can't find a needle in a needle stack sometimes MEADE !!! the forum SLACKER !!! .. lol
    1 point
  42. i know he made it...but i didn't see he posted it anywhere...but then again this forum is so damn busy i can't find a needle in a needle stack sometimes
    1 point
  43. this shit is fun - i love the suspense of watching you guys guess...knowing if someone hits, it's gonna cost me a few hundred $$. Totally worth it though Ill do more testing i promise but i gotta keep the amps smaller or get a bigger power supply. My pocket book has to get bigger or get a bigger "supply" first though cuz this shit isn't cheap thanks to all who participated! to the noobs - stay friendly, make some friends, learn some shit, stay a while!
    1 point
  44. damn....hope he is ok....doesnt seem like him to do that
    1 point
  45. i think you'd stick your dick in a blender if it told you it was 40 wtih two kids your age. lol
    1 point
×
×
  • Create New...